The Unthinkable Handshake That Could Redraw the Middle East

The Unthinkable Handshake That Could Redraw the Middle East

Silence.

That is what usually follows when someone in Ramallah suggests that Benjamin Netanyahu and Gadi Eisenkot might eventually share a cabinet table. You can hear the distant hum of the Mediterranean, the clatter of small glass teacups on metal trays, and the sudden, sharp intake of breath from people who have spent decades mapping the fault lines of Israeli-Palestinian politics.

Yet, that exact whisper has begun circulating through the backchannels of Jerusalem and the West Bank. When a former senior official of the Palestine Liberation Organization recently floated the possibility of a future coalition between Israel’s longest-serving prime minister and one of his fiercest centrist critics, the reaction across standard news feeds was predictable. Pundits scoffed. Analysts pulled up voting records, ideological manifestos, and bitter personal histories to prove why such an alliance is mathematically and emotionally impossible.

They are looking at the spreadsheet. They are missing the survival instinct.

To understand why a Netanyahu-Eisenkot coalition is not merely a bizarre parlor game for political junkies, you have to step away from the podiums and look at what happens when two men—who genuinely despise each other’s methods—realize they are locked in the same burning building.

Ghosts in the War Room

Picture a hypothetical scene inside a windowless room beneath the Kirya military headquarters in Tel Aviv. Let us call the two men at the table what they actually are: architects of entirely different visions of survival.

On one side sits Benjamin Netanyahu, a man whose political obituary has been written so many times that he practically collects the clippings as wallpaper. For over fifteen years in power, his survival strategy relied on maintaining delicate, often volatile balances—managing conflicts rather than resolving them, leaning heavily on right-wing and ultra-Orthodox blocs to keep his parliamentary majority intact.

Across from him sits Gadi Eisenkot, the former Chief of Staff of the Israel Defense Forces. Eisenkot does not speak in the soaring, combative rhetoric of career politicians. He speaks like a logistics officer who has seen too many young men carried home in flag-draped coffins—including his own son, Gal, killed in Gaza in late 2023. When Eisenkot joined the emergency war cabinet after October 7, he did not do it out of affection for Netanyahu. He did it because the house was on fire. When he walked out months later, accusing the prime minister of letting personal political survival dictate military strategy, the break looked permanent.

So why would a veteran PLO insider—someone who has spent a lifetime watching Israeli political maneuvering from the outside looking in—suggest these two might end up bound together again?

Because in the Middle East, political hatred is a luxury people abandon the moment existential math changes.

The Arithmetic of Desperation

Consider the trap both men currently inhabit.

In Israel’s parliamentary system, winning an election is rarely about securing a landslide; it is about cobbling together 61 seats out of 120 in the Knesset. For years, Netanyahu’s magic number depended on hardline nationalist partners like Itamar Ben-Gvir and Bezalel Smotrich. That alliance kept him in the prime minister’s chair, yes, but it came at a staggering diplomatic price. Every incendiary statement from his far-right flank eroded Israel’s standing in Washington, stalled regional normalization efforts with Saudi Arabia, and turned routine diplomatic summits into hostage negotiations over domestic coalition stability.

At the same time, look at the center-left opposition. Figures like Benny Gantz and Gadi Eisenkot command deep respect among weary middle-class Israelis—people like a fictional Tel Aviv software engineer named Avi, who spent four months in reserve duty, returned to a stagnating economy, and just wants a government that functions without tearing the country apart at the seams. Yet, the opposition has repeatedly struggled to form a cohesive alternative block without relying on smaller factions that have their own rigid red lines.

When both sides hit a wall, politics reverts to its oldest law: the enemy of my paralysis is my temporary partner.

A former PLO official watching this deadlock does not see ideological purity. They see two veterans of the Israeli security establishment who know that neither the hard right nor a fractured opposition can single-handedly navigate the post-war diplomatic labyrinth. If an election ends in another deadlock, or if international pressure—particularly from Washington—demands a governing coalition capable of actually negotiating regional security arrangements, the impossible suddenly becomes the only exit door left unlocked.

Why Ramallah Is Watching Closely

You might wonder why a former PLO official would even bother weighing in on internal Israeli coalition mechanics. To an outsider, it sounds like an observer commenting on a chess match they aren't allowed to play.

Nothing could be further from the truth.

For Palestinians living in Ramallah, Nablus, or the shattered neighborhoods of Gaza, the composition of the Israeli cabinet is not an abstract political debate. It determines whether checkpoints open at six in the morning or stay locked until noon. It dictates whether tax revenues collected on behalf of the Palestinian Authority are transferred or frozen. It decides whether there is a diplomatic horizon—however faint—or simply endless military administration.

Let us be candid about something that often gets lost in sanitized diplomatic reporting: for years, segments of the Palestinian leadership viewed Netanyahu as a known quantity, a status-quo operator who preferred quiet management over dramatic upheaval. That illusion died violently on October 7. Since then, the reliance of Netanyahu’s government on ultranationalist ministers who openly advocate for dismantling the Palestinian Authority and expanding settlements indefinitely has terrified Ramallah.

Enter Gadi Eisenkot.

To Palestinian officials, Eisenkot is by no means a dove. He is a career general who oversaw major military operations in Gaza and Lebanon. They harbor no illusions about his commitment to Israeli military dominance. Yet, in the pragmatic calculus of Ramallah, Eisenkot represents something desperately missing from the current Israeli cabinet: strategic predictability and a willingness to engage with regional partners, including moderate Arab states and a reformed Palestinian leadership, to construct a post-war framework.

When a former PLO official suggests that a Netanyahu-Eisenkot coalition could happen, they are not making a starry-eyed prediction. They are signaling a preference—and a warning. They are saying that if Netanyahu wants a lifeline back to legitimacy in Washington and Riyadh, he will eventually have to dump his far-right partners and reach back toward the pragmatic center. And if he does, Palestinians will be dealing with an entirely different beast at the negotiating table.

The Anatomy of an Unholy Alliance

History is littered with political marriages that looked absurd until the morning they were announced.

In 1984, Shimon Peres and Yitzhak Shamir—men whose ideological divide was practically religious—formed a national unity government because hyperinflation was destroying the Israeli economy and neither could govern alone. They rotated the prime ministership, glared at each other across cabinet tables, and stabilized the country. More recently, in 2020, Benny Gantz swore up and down to millions of voters that he would never sit under Benjamin Netanyahu—right up until the COVID-19 pandemic hit, at which point he walked into the cabinet room and signed a coalition deal.

Critics argue that the bad blood between Netanyahu and Eisenkot runs too deep for a repeat of 2020. Eisenkot has publicly questioned Netanyahu’s fitness to lead during a crisis. He has watched the prime minister’s allies attack the military leadership Eisenkot spent his life building.

But step into the shoes of a strategist looking at the next twenty-four months. Suppose an election is called. Neither the pro-Netanyahu bloc nor the anti-Netanyahu bloc reaches the magic threshold of 61 seats. The country faces a fifth or sixth election cycle in a span of years while rockets still fly in the north and hostages or diplomatic crises remain unresolved.

In that pressure cooker, the conversation shifts.

Eisenkot has never been driven by personal vanity. Unlike politicians who crave the title of prime minister for its own sake, his entire public persona is built around duty—sometimes grim, thankless duty. If he is presented with a scenario where joining a unity government is the sole mechanism to remove extremist ministers from control of the police and finance ministries, to secure a hostage deal, or to lock in a regional defense pact with the United States and Saudi Arabia, would he really say no just to preserve his personal pride?

Anyone who knows how military minds operate knows the answer. You do not refuse to take a hill just because you dislike the commander standing next to you.

And what about Netanyahu? For a man obsessed with his historical legacy, ending his career tethered exclusively to fringe ideologues who isolate Israel from its closest allies is a nightmare scenario. A pivot back to the center—even a bruised, hostile, reluctant pivot involving Eisenkot—would allow Netanyahu to recast himself as the indispensable elder statesman who bridged the divide when the nation needed him most.

What Everyone Gets Wrong About Political Trust

The biggest mistake observers make when analyzing Middle Eastern politics is assuming that coalitions require trust.

💡 You might also like: The Weight of the Heavy Hand

They don't. They require leverage.

In Western democracies, we often romanticize political partnerships as alignments of shared values. In the crucible of Levantine politics, alliances are closer to structural engineering: two opposing beams leaning against each other so neither collapses into the dirt.

If Netanyahu and Eisenkot ever sit in the same government again, there will be no warmth in the room. There will be ironclad coalition agreements, veto powers written into the fine print, and constant, grinding friction over every judicial appointment and military directive. Every morning would start with suspicion; every evening would end with calculated leaks to the press.

Yet, think about what that friction produces compared to the unchecked momentum of an ideological echo chamber. Friction slows things down. It forces compromise. It prevents the most extreme impulses of either side from becoming state policy overnight. For millions of ordinary people—both Israelis exhausted by internal division and Palestinians desperate for a glimmer of diplomatic sanity—a tense, begrudging stalemate between pragmatists is infinitely preferable to an ideological runaway train.

The View From the Street

I remember standing on a ridge overlooking Jerusalem at dusk a few years ago, watching the lights flicker on across both the western neighborhoods and the eastern villages. From up there, you cannot see the invisible lines drawn on diplomatic maps. You just see stone houses clinging to the same rocky hills, people rushing home from work, traffic snarling at intersections, life stubbornly insisting on continuing despite the grand, tragic pronouncements of politicians.

Down on those streets, nobody is waiting for a miracle. People have been burned too many times by promises of historic breakthroughs and permanent peace. What they want is something far simpler, yet infinitely harder to achieve: adults in the room who understand the weight of the decisions they make.

The former PLO official who floated the idea of a Netanyahu-Eisenkot coalition understands this exhaustion intimately. Having spent decades navigating the corridors of power in Ramallah, Tunis, and Washington, you develop a sixth sense for when the ground is shifting beneath the surface, long before the seismic needles start jumping on the evening news.

Whether that specific coalition ever materializes depends on a dozen unpredictable variables—the timing of the next Israeli election, the shifting political winds in Washington, the internal power struggles within the Palestinian leadership itself. It might never happen. Ego, pride, and old wounds might prove too heavy to lift, even for men accustomed to carrying impossible burdens.

Still, the mere fact that serious observers on the Palestinian side are gaming out the scenario tells you everything you need to know about the current moment. The old formulas have failed. The comfortable alliances have rotted from the inside out.

Somewhere in Jerusalem, a political aide is already drafting talking points for an alliance that his boss currently swears will never happen. And somewhere in Ramallah, an aging diplomat is pouring another cup of bitter coffee, waiting to see which enemies will finally decide they need each other more than they hate each other.

OP

Oliver Park

Driven by a commitment to quality journalism, Oliver Park delivers well-researched, balanced reporting on today's most pressing topics.