Stop Obsessing Over Wealth Taxes and Fix the Capital Loopholes Instead

Stop Obsessing Over Wealth Taxes and Fix the Capital Loopholes Instead

Everyone wants to tax the rich, and almost everyone proposes doing it in the exact way that fails in the real world.

The current academic consensus—championed by economists like Princeton’s Owen Zidar and Berkeley’s Emmanuel Saez and Gabriel Zucman—argues that we have finally figured out how to corner the ultra-wealthy. According to Zidar’s research on top-earner taxation, the rich aren't just salaried executives collecting W-2 paychecks anymore; they are pass-through business owners, private equity partners, and founders holding massive pools of private capital. The proposed fix from the mainstream progressive camp is predictable: hike top marginal income rates, close pass-through deductions, and slap an annual wealth tax on net worth.

It sounds clean on a whiteboard. In practice, it is an administrative nightmare that misunderstands how modern capital actually moves, hides, and compounds.

I have spent years watching tax attorneys and family offices dismantle statutory rate hikes before the ink on the legislation is even dry. When lawmakers raise headline tax rates without fixing the foundational definitions of income and realization, they do not collect more revenue from billionaires. They simply create a massive stimulus package for estate planners, valuation consultants, and offshore structuring firms.

If you want to understand why the conventional approach to taxing the rich stalls out, you have to look at the mechanics of modern wealth—not the idealized models of academic economists.

The Myth of the Simple Wealth Tax

The lazy consensus in modern tax policy assumes that because we know who the billionaires are on the Forbes list, the IRS can simply send them a bill for 2% or 3% of their net worth every April.

Owen Zidar and his co-authors have done genuinely valuable empirical work showing that top earners derive the bulk of their income from private businesses—S-corporations, partnerships, and sole proprietorships—rather than traditional wages. Their data proves that the "working rich" are largely business owners who retain earnings inside corporate wrappers to shield themselves from personal income taxes. That diagnosis is spot-on.

The prescription, however, runs straight into a brick wall of valuation physics.

Roughly 80% to 90% of the wealth held by the top 0.1% is not sitting in liquid, publicly traded shares of Apple or Microsoft. It is locked inside illiquid, private operating businesses, venture funds, commercial real estate syndications, and complex multi-tiered trusts. How do you value a private software company that hasn't raised a funding round in four years? How do you assess a minority stake in a family-owned logistics empire with strict transfer restrictions?

Europe already ran this experiment, and the results were unambiguous. In 1990, twelve OECD countries levied net wealth taxes. By 2018, only three remained—Norway, Spain, and Switzerland—and each had to carve out massive exemptions for business assets just to keep domestic companies from liquidating or relocating. France’s famous Solidarity Tax on Wealth (ISF) cost more in capital flight and suppressed domestic investment than it ever raised at the treasury, forcing Emmanuel Macron to scrap it in 2017 and replace it with a narrow tax on real estate.

When you force private business owners to pay an annual tax on illiquid paper gains, you create a liquidity crunch. Either they sell off pieces of their company to foreign buyers to pay the IRS, or they hire armies of appraisers to argue their company is worth 40% less than it actually is. The IRS does not have the manpower to litigate ten thousand bespoke valuation battles every single spring.

You Are Asking the Wrong Question About Tax Rates

Whenever tax policy hits the news, the public debate immediately fixates on a single number: the top marginal rate. Should it be 37%? 39.6%? 50%? 70%?

That is the wrong question. The headline rate is largely a theatrical number designed for political campaigns. What actually determines how much tax the ultra-wealthy pay is the tax base—specifically, what counts as taxable income, when it gets triggered, and what happens to it when the owner dies.

Consider how an ultra-high-net-worth individual actually funds their lifestyle. They do not sell stock and trigger a 20% or 23.8% federal capital gains tax. They use a strategy known in private banking circles as Buy, Borrow, Die:

  1. Buy: Acquire appreciating assets—private equity, real estate, founder shares—that pay little to no taxable dividends.
  2. Borrow: Pledge those assets as collateral for a bespoke securities-backed line of credit (SBLOC) at a fraction of the cost of capital gains taxes. Loan proceeds are debt, not income, meaning they are 100% tax-free.
  3. Die: Hold the assets until death. Under Section 1014 of the Internal Revenue Code, the cost basis of those assets automatically resets—or "steps up"—to their fair market value on the date of death. All the unrealized gains accumulated over a lifetime are permanently erased from the tax system.

Raising the top income tax rate from 37% to 45% does literally nothing to touch this engine. You could raise the top ordinary income rate to 90% tomorrow, and a billionaire living off credit lines backed by unrealized founder equity would still report an adjusted gross income near zero.

Why Pass-Through Reform Only Solves Half the Problem

Zidar’s research rightly targets the pass-through loophole—the system where business profits flow directly to owners' personal tax returns, often qualifying for the 20% Qualified Business Income (QBI) deduction introduced in 2017, while dodging the 3.8% Net Investment Income Tax (NIIT) through active-participation rules.

Closing that gap is necessary, yet stopping there leaves the biggest escape hatch wide open. If Congress jacks up tax rates on pass-through entities like S-corps and partnerships while leaving the corporate tax rate at 21%, wealthy business owners will simply convert their entities into C-corporations.

We saw this exact behavior in reverse after the 1986 Tax Reform Act, and we saw it swing back toward C-corps after 2017. Business owners are hyper-responsive to rate arbitrage. If a C-corp pays 21% at the entity level and retains its earnings internally—reinvesting profits into new acquisitions, real estate, or treasury bills—the owner pays zero personal tax until a dividend is issued or shares are sold. And if those shares are held until death, the personal tax never arrives at all.

Economists like Alan Auerbach at UC Berkeley and Edward Kleinbard have long pointed out that treating corporate income, pass-through income, and capital gains as separate silos guarantees endless gaming. Every boundary line you draw in the tax code becomes a profit center for tax lawyers paid $1,500 an hour to move money across that line.

People Also Ask: Dismantling the Common Talking Points

Don't the rich already pay the vast majority of federal income taxes?
Yes, when you look strictly at federal individual income taxes on realized, reported income. According to IRS Statistics of Income data, the top 1% of earners pay roughly 40% to 45% of all federal individual income taxes. However, that statistic relies on a narrow denominator. It excludes payroll taxes (which cap out and hit middle-class workers hardest), state and local sales taxes, and—most critically—tens of trillions of dollars in unrealized capital gains that never show up on a Form 1040. When you measure total taxes paid against true economic income (including unrealized appreciation), the effective tax rate for the top 0.001% drops sharply below that of a surgeon or senior software engineer.

If we raise taxes on business owners, won't they stop investing and hiring?
The empirical evidence on this is far messier than supply-side orthodoxy admits. Zidar’s own research with Eric Zwick shows that tax cuts for the top 1% primarily boost payouts to owners and shareholders rather than sparking massive surges in capital expenditure or worker wages. Conversely, poorly designed taxes on gross assets or illiquid business equity do distort investment by penalizing capital-intensive firms with low short-term cash flows. The goal isn't to punish investment; it is to stop subsidizing idle wealth accumulation and debt-fueled tax avoidance.

Why can't we just enforce the current tax laws harder?
Enforcement matters—the IRS estimates the annual "tax gap" (taxes owed but not paid) exceeds $600 billion, heavily concentrated at the top where complex partnerships hide audit trails. Yet even a fully funded army of IRS auditors can only collect taxes that the law actually levies. Buying, borrowing, and dying is completely legal. No amount of auditing fixes a broken statute.

The Contrarian Fix: Ditch the Wealth Tax and Target Realization Events

If we want a system that actually captures revenue from ultra-high-net-worth individuals without creating an unworkable valuation bureaucracy, we need to abandon the dream of an annual net wealth tax and attack the real mechanisms of tax-free compounding.

Here is what actually works:

1. Kill the Stepped-Up Basis at Death

Repeal Section 1014 and treat death as a realization event—a reform known as constructive realization, which Canada has used since 1972. When a billionaire passes away, their accumulated capital gains are taxed at the applicable capital gains rate before the estate passes to heirs, with reasonable exemptions (say, $5 million to $10 million) and installment payment options for family farms or illiquid operating businesses. Eliminating the stepped-up basis immediately destroys the "Die" leg of the Buy, Borrow, Die strategy.

2. Tax Borrowing Against Unrealized Gains

If an asset is liquid and certain enough to be pledged to JPMorgan or Goldman Sachs as collateral for a $100 million personal loan, it is certain enough to be taxed. Congress should treat loans collateralized by appreciated assets above a high threshold (such as $10 million) as a constructive sale to the extent of the loan proceeds. Once borrowing triggers a tax event, the financial incentive to hoard appreciated stock indefinitely evaporates overnight.

3. Equalize Capital Gains and Ordinary Income Rates—With Inflation Indexing

The preferential rate for long-term capital gains exists to encourage risk-taking and compensate investors for inflation, yet in practice it functions as a massive subsidy for private equity carried interest and passive asset appreciation. Taxing capital gains at the same top rate as wages eliminates the primary incentive to disguise labor income as investment returns. To keep it fair and economically sound, pair that rate hike with inflation indexing of the cost basis—so investors are only taxed on real economic gains, not nominal price increases caused by Federal Reserve money printing.

4. Replace the Corporate Tax Maze with a Destination-Based Cash Flow Tax

Instead of arguing over whether the corporate rate should be 21% or 28% while multinational tech and pharma giants shift intellectual property to Ireland and Singapore, move toward taxing cash flows where customers actually buy products. Businesses deduct capital expenditures immediately, interest deductions are eliminated (removing the tax bias toward corporate debt), and profit-shifting to offshore tax havens becomes mathematically irrelevant.

The Downsides Nobody Likes to Admit

Every tax reform involves ugly trade-offs, and pretending otherwise is dishonest.

Treating death as a realization event and taxing collateralized loans will force some founders to sell shares earlier than they want, potentially diluting their voting control over companies they built. Equalizing capital gains and ordinary income rates will reduce the after-tax return on venture capital and early-stage angel investing, which could dampen risk appetite at the margins during economic downturns. And any tightening of domestic corporate or estate rules will always push a sliver of ultra-mobile billionaires to renounce citizenship or relocate their primary tax residency to jurisdictions like Dubai, Monaco, or Singapore—even with exit taxes in place.

Those trade-offs are real, and policymakers have to price them in.

Still, those friction costs pale in comparison to the fantasy of administering an annual wealth tax on private partnerships, fine art, and closely held businesses—or pretending that tweaking top wage brackets will ever touch people who don't earn wages.

Stop chasing headline income rates and unworkable wealth appraisals. Close the stepped-up basis, tax collateralized borrowing, and watch how fast the effective tax rate at the top finally matches the statutory code.

OP

Oliver Park

Driven by a commitment to quality journalism, Oliver Park delivers well-researched, balanced reporting on today's most pressing topics.